Best Bark Collar: Types and Benefits

Being able to control the level of noise your dog makes is an essential aspect of responsible owner behavior. Your first priority is to find out why the pet is doing this and take all the necessary actions. If your pup is feeling well, you can use special collars as an addition to proper training.

I have reviewed all the products on the market and have compiled a list of 7 items that will effectively help you in raising your dog. In my opinion, STOPWOOFER No Shock Bark Collar is the best bark collar due to its versatility and gentle effect on dog behavior.

Best Overall
Product
No Shock Bark Collar for Small Medium and Large Dogs...
Prime
-
Pros
Suitable for dogs of any fur length
My review
Best for Small Dogs
Product
Small Dog Bark Collar Rechargeable - Anti Barking...
Price
Prime
Pros
Long battery life
My review
Best for Large Dogs
Product
BRISON Dog Bark Collar - 3 Modes Beep Vibration -...
Price
Prime
-
Pros
100% waterproof
My review
Product
Citronella Spray Bark Collar, Automatic Training Bark...
Price
Prime
Pros
Lightweight (3.5 ounces)
My review
Product
GoodBoy Mini Remote Dog Training Collar GB807V Extra...
Price
Prime
Pros
Gently affects the dog
My review

It is important to choose the right accessory since constant barking can annoy not only you but also your neighbors. Besides, a collar should not cause pain or discomfort to your pet and influence its behavior in a humane way.

Stop Dog Barking Safely

Consistency is vital in all aspects of training. Dogs respond well to routine actions, and this will significantly increase your chances of success. Since many owners are not always at home, controlling a dog’s behavior can be difficult. That is why you need a device that will work automatically.

Remember that barking is a natural way for dogs to communicate and get the attention of their owner. It is important to choose a behavior control tool that does not make a dog fear to voice. I highly discourage using stop barking collars with built-in tasers or rattles. Such devices are inhumane; they will only scare or even hurt your pet, but will not change its behavior for the better.

Of course, such products cannot do all the work instead of the dog’s owner. They are just a useful aid. You, too, need to pay attention to your pet and reward it for the correct behavior. So when your dog stops barking, praise it, and give it a treat. At first, this should be done right away, so that the doggie understands the connection: stops barking – gets a treat. After a while, you can increase the interval between stopping the barking and rewarding.

back to menu ↑

Best Bark Collar Reviews

In my review, I’ve only included humane items that delicately affect dog behavior. The principle of operation of such collars is the same: inside, they have built-in sensors that are triggered when a dog starts barking. Over time, your pet will learn this pattern and stop barking for no reason.

back to menu ↑

The Best Dog Bark Collar Overall: STOPWOOFER No Shock Bark Collar

STOPWOOFER No Shock Bark Collar is a versatile model that will fit any dog breed (from 7 to 120 pounds). Its length is adjustable from 6.7 to 21.65 inches. The strap itself is made from thick waterproof nylon, and the body of the device is made of plastic. Conveniently, this collar has two reflective stripes so that you can walk your dog even at night.

The device uses vibration and sound to influence a dog. The sensor installed inside is very sensitive and detects several types of barks. Thanks to this, over time, your pup will stop responding to passing cars or passers-by. It works automatically, so you don’t need to be around your pet all the time to correct its behavior.

Two 4LR44 6 volt batteries power the device (they are included in the kit). Unfortunately, there is no display here that would show the charge level, so the device may stop working at the most unexpected moment.

The collar has seven levels of impact, depending on bark duration. At first, it warns a dog only by sound, but after a while, vibration is additionally triggered. For example, the maximum possible duration of work is 4 seconds of sound and 2.5 seconds of vibration. Also, you can adjust its sensitivity, depending on the volume of your pet’s voice.

Positives:
  • Adjustable length;
  • Sensitivity adjustment;
  • Suitable for dogs of any fur length.
Negatives:
  • Runs on batteries.
back to menu ↑

The Best Bark Collar for Small Dogs: ELECANE Small Dog Bark Collar

Automatic ELECANE Small Dog Bark Collar is specially designed for the smallest dogs (from 4 to 50 pounds). If your pet has a neck diameter of 6-20 inches, then this device is an excellent choice. Since it automatically turns on to a dog barking, you don’t need to be around all the time.

A rechargeable battery powers the device. On average, one charge lasting 1.5 hours is enough for two weeks of work without interruption.

With such a collar, you can walk your pet in any weather as it is entirely waterproof. And the reflective stripes are visible even at dusk.

Training accessories should be humane and safe in any case, but for small breeds with thin necks and delicate skin, it is especially important. You can adjust the sensitivity of the device depending on the individual characteristics of your pet. It is activated only to your dog’s voice and does not respond to other barking doggies, since it is not enabled by sound, but by throat vibrations.

Best Bark Collar for Small Dogs: Train Your Dog Safely

Automatic tools are the most effective because your pet will see a constant pattern between barking and collar activation. Of course, the speed of learning depends on the individual characteristics of the breed. However, the manufacturer claims that 14 days is enough for the dog to learn the lesson. If your experience is unsuccessful, the company is ready to return the money.

Positives:
  • Thin and lightweight;
  • Triggered by voice vibrations;
  • Long battery life.
Negatives:
  • The size is not universal, it fits only small dogs;
  • May not work well on fluffy dogs.
back to menu ↑

The Best Humane Bark Collar for Large Dogs: BRISON Dog Bark Collar

If you are the lucky owner of a large breed dog, I recommend that you pay attention to BRISON Dog Bark Collar. Unlike previous models, I like that this one has a digital display that shows the charge level and operating mode of the device. It is very convenient, as it will prevent you from getting into a situation where the collar suddenly runs out.

This model fits perfectly with dogs weighing 20 to 110 pounds and a neck diameter of 7.1 to 26.3 inches. The set comes with two types of contacts: for short-haired and long-haired breeds (mini spanner is included in the kit). Although the manufacturer calls it universal, I would recommend buying it only for medium or large dogs.

The strap is made of soft but dense TPU; it is quite wide and may not be suitable for small dogs’ necks. In my opinion, the manufacturer should have chosen a more durable material for the collar itself.

BRISON’s large dog bark collars are completely waterproof, and their bright LED displays are visible even in bad weather. The devices have three modes of operation: vibration, sound, and a gradual increase in intensity. If you have any difficulties with setting them up, you can find all the information you need in the attached manual. They run on batteries that can be recharged using the supplied USB cable.

Positives:
  • Rechargeable with a USB cable;
  • 100% waterproof;
  • Additional accessories are included.
Negatives:
  • The belt seems a bit flimsy;
  • Only for large dogs.
back to menu ↑

The Best Spray No Shock Bark Collar: Citronella Spray Bark Collar

If all previous models had a vibration-sound type of effect, then Citronella Spray Bark Collar affects dogs with a smell. It is controlled by a chip that, at the sound of a dog barking, opens a miniature valve and releases a small amount of citronella plant spray from the reservoir.

Thus, when barking, your dog receives an unpleasant signal in the form of sound (hissing), a visual cloud of spray, and a plant smell. So the pet quickly realizes that when it gives a voice, small unpleasantly smelling splashes fly.

The collar itself is adjustable in size and fits dogs over 8 pounds and with neck diameters from 8 to 27 inches. The company makes them from nylon and rubber, but you cannot choose the material; they are sent to customers at random. The built-in battery is rechargeable using a USB cable. One full charge (2-3 hours) lasts about seven days of use.

If you have a long-haired dog, you will need to trim its fur where the fluid is being sprayed. So the smell will definitely reach the dog’s nose. I do not recommend wearing this collar all the time; try to use it no more than 8 hours daily. The manufacturer also recommends refilling the device before every walk, but the spray is not included.

Positives:
  • Absolutely safe for pets;
  • There is an indicator of charge and amount of spray;
  • Lightweight (3.5 ounces).
Negatives:
  • The spray is not included;
  • May not be effective for long-haired dogs.
back to menu ↑

The Best Remote Control Bark Collar: GoodBoy Mini Remote Dog Training Collar

The GoodBoy company manufactures different collars and remote controls that are compatible with each other. So you can get a GoodBoy Mini Remote Dog Training Collar for one or more of your pets and use one remote control for all.

This model is designed exclusively for extra small and small dogs (from 5 to 15 pounds). The maximum collar length is 26 inches. When choosing an accessory for small breeds, it is also essential to pay attention to the weight of a product. This collar weighs only 1.76 ounces; it will not rub your pup’s neck.

Small dogs, by nature, are very sensitive to loud sounds. That is why this collar has only one intensity level and nine vibration modes. It does not work automatically, but exclusively from the remote control. The device is powerful enough to activate the sensor even at a distance of 100 feet. It is powered by a lithium battery, one charge lasting up to 16 hours of continuous operation.

Since the device does not automatically activate, you cannot be sure that the dog will not bark in your absence. But you can use it to correct any other behavior. For example, if your dog likes chewing on things or digging in flower beds, you can turn the collar on to stop it. Some users even report the significant impact of these devices on their cats’ behavior.

Positives:
  • Gently affects the dog;
  • Extra lightweight;
  • You can use it not only to control barking.
Negatives:
  • Not automatic;
  • For some stubborn dogs, its gentle vibration may not be enough.
back to menu ↑

Universal Vibrating Bark Collars: Authen Bark Collar No Shock

Authen Bark Collar No Shock is a truly versatile piece. Its length can be changed depending on the weight of your pet. It is suitable for dogs from 8 to 150 pounds.

Unlike previous models, a double motor is installed inside this device, which allows you to turn on especially strong vibrations. You can choose one of two types: normal vibrations or enhanced ones, and then adjust the desired power from 1 to 6. It is not recommended to use this collar for more than 12 hours daily.

The collar is activated on barking from 80 to 90db and 1000 to 2000 kHz and does not turn on when other pets bark nearby. One battery charge is enough for two weeks of regular use. Please note that the charging voltage is not universal and is limited to 5V. Otherwise, the device will overheat and give a warning signal. Using the supplied USB cable, you can charge the collar from a computer, power bank, and even a car charger.

This device is waterproof and resistant to bad weather conditions. You can easily spot your pet by the two bright reflective stripes along the item in poor visibility. The collar itself is made of nylon, so you can trim off any excess if needed to keep it from loose and irritating your dog.

Positives:
  • One size fits all;
  • Bright reflective stripes;
  • Waterproof.
Negatives:
  • Cannot be worn for more than 12 hours a day;
  • Limited voltage.
back to menu ↑

Durable and Waterproof Anti Bark Collar: AHJDL Dog Bark Collar

AHJDL Dog Bark Collar is another versatile model for small, medium, and large dogs from 3 months old. It affects the dog with sound and vibrations, but also has a switchable shock option. And for this very reason, this collar is at the bottom of my list. Remember that only humane devices should be used to train a pet. Before first use, make sure this mode is off (zero should appear when you press the lightning button).

The other two modes work the same way as on most similar devices. You can adjust the sensor’s sensitivity, and the vibration and sound will increase if the dog continues to bark for a while. The built-in battery is charged from the USB cable, and one charge lasts on average from 10 to 15 days of regular use. It only takes about 2-3 hours to recharge it fully.

The collar itself is made of durable nylon and has no holes. It easily adjusts to your dog’s neck diameter but may loosen while wearing. Remember to check it periodically and tighten it when needed. If it dangles too much, the pet simply will not feel vibrations. You need to choose the size in the same way as a regular collar: so that one or two fingers fit between the dog’s neck and the belt.

Positives:
  • Water-resistant;
  • One charge lasts for a long time;
  • Fast charging.
Negatives:
  • May become loose during a walk;
  • There is a shock option.
back to menu ↑

Safe Bark Collars Buyer’s Guide

dog barks

In this section, I will tell you in detail how to choose from among the many top rated bark collars the accessory that will be most effective for your pet.

back to menu ↑

What is a bark collar?

It is a special device for correcting pup behavior. Bark collars have microphones or other sensors that respond to a pet’s voice or throat vibrations. Depending on the type chosen (citronella spray or vibration, for example), it distracts the dog’s attention, forcing it to be silent. The key to the effectiveness of these devices lies in their regular use.

back to menu ↑

Types of bark collars

There are currently four types of such collars:

  • Vibration devices. From the name, it is clear that such collars affect dogs by releasing a series of vibrations. The longer the dog barks, the stronger and more intense they will be.
  • Sound devices. Some tools emit “beeps,” and there are those that emit ultrasound. In any case, the noise emitted is unpleasant for the dog’s ear.
  • Spray devices. These collars release a stream of stinky repellent based on natural ingredients. The most common sprays are with citronella.
  • Static shock devices. They use electrodes that conduct current to the dog’s skin. I highly recommend that you do not use shock collars or disable this feature if possible.
back to menu ↑

How to use a bark collar?

Best Bark Collar

It is put around your dog’s neck like a usual collar. However, it cannot be worn all the time without taking it off. Barking is a natural dog’s way of communicating. Dog barking control devices should not make your pet stop voicing altogether. How many hours a day, you can use them directly depends on your dog’s intelligence and character. Some pets learn quite quickly, and they need several hours daily to consolidate the result. Other pups need more time. Anyway, do not put the collar on your pet for more than 12 hours.

back to menu ↑

Things to consider before buying a bark collar

Besides the fact that the collars themselves are different, each dog is also individual. When choosing the most effective bark collar, pay attention to the following characteristics:

  • Weight of your dog. Most manufacturers in their product descriptions indicate the weight of the dog for which the collar was designed. My experience shows that universal models are not suitable for all dogs. Therefore, I recommend choosing collars explicitly designed for small (3+ pounds) or large (over 100 pounds) breeds.
  • Your dog’s neck size. This parameter is even more important than the pet’s weight. The diameter of the neck rather depends not on the dog’s weight, but its breed and body shape. Measure your pet’s neck before purchasing a collar, or use the size of its usual one.
  • False-trigger proofing feature. It is crucial that the device is activated only by the barking of your pet, and not by the dogs standing nearby. Only in this case, bark collars will be effective. Otherwise, your pup will not understand why it is being punished if it did nothing wrong.
  • Adjustments of the device sensitivity. Skin sensitivity, fur density, and character vary from dog to dog. The device should have an option to adjust the sensitivity so that your pet can feel it for sure.
  • Durability. Choose a collar made of the most durable materials (e.g., nylon). Make sure the housing is secure and will not break from a few careless movements. I also recommend choosing waterproof equipment so that you can train your dog in any weather.
back to menu ↑

Benefits and disadvantages of using a bark collar

A bark collar should serve as an assistant in the process of raising a dog. Keep in mind that the right pet’s behavior is the owner’s job. Use this collar in conjunction with other methods of behavior control, and then it will be effective.

Of the minuses of such devices, it is worth noting their negative impact on timid dogs. If your pet is shy, even a delicate small dog vibration bark collar can make it stop barking at all. For these pets, you should find a different approach to training.

back to menu ↑

FAQs About Good Bark Collars

dog wearing bark collar

In this section, I have picked answers to the most popular questions from dog owners. And if you have your question, feel free to ask me in the comments section.

back to menu ↑

Are bark collars safe?

It depends on the type of collar. All devices that use sound, vibrations, or sprays are absolutely safe. As for those with a shock option, it is difficult to give a definite answer. Their effect is similar to the sensations we experience when struck by static electricity. There is currently no research that says it is totally harmless to dogs. That is why all experts recommend not using such collars.

back to menu ↑

Do bark collars work?

Again, the key to success lies in an integrated approach. Without an owner’s work with a dog, the effectiveness of such collars will not be 100%. In case you spend enough time with your pet and use assistive devices, they really work. Do not forget that much depends on the character of the dog. Some individuals are especially stubborn and do not specifically pay attention to vibration and sound.

back to menu ↑

How often should I use a bark collar?

It is recommended to use them daily, but do not leave them on the dog for the whole day. Any automatic bark collar should work as a part of the training, and you should give your pet time to rest and socialize with other dogs. Do not leave such a device on your pet for more than 12 hours.

back to menu ↑

How to test a PetSafe bark collar?

The PetSafe bark collar is based on the use of static shock. If you do decide to use this type of device, please test it before using it. Turn the sensors to any flat surface and slide them for 10 inches or more. The device should emit a corresponding signal, which means that it works correctly. Do not touch the sensors with your hands when the collar is turned on.

back to menu ↑

How tight should a bark collar be?

As with regular collars, there should be enough space between the belt and the dog’s neck for you to get one or two fingers through. If your dog is very fluffy, you may need to trim a little in the area where the sensors are attached. At the same time, the collar should sit tightly enough so that the built-in sensors touch the dog’s neck and respond to barking timely.

back to menu ↑

Do bark collars help with howling or whining?

Bark collars sensors respond to any voice or throat vibrations. Depending on the sensitivity of a picked device, they can also be triggered by dogs howling and whining. Choose a product that recognizes both voice and vibrations, then it will work more correctly and will not respond to the noise of other dogs.

back to menu ↑

Are there any other ways to train a dog to stop barking?

First of all, you need to understand why your dog barks. Perhaps your pet feels pain, anxiety, or fear of something. In this case, you should show it to your veterinarian. Otherwise, barking can express joy (while playing), boredom (if the owner is out of home), or can be an attempt to manipulate you.

It is important to teach your dog to follow the “Quiet!” command. You should be able to make the pet stop barking when you need it. If your doggie is very active, channel its energies into something useful: throw it a ball or frisbee. The pup will get pretty tired, and will not worry that you are not around. You can distract the dog’s attention by lightly grabbing it by the ears. This behavior on your part will confuse it, and you can divert its focus from the stimulus.

back to menu ↑

Ready to Try the Best No Bark Collars?

As you can see, there are many options for bark collars, and the choice of the most suitable accessory directly depends on your pet’s individual characteristics. Remember that most companies provide refunds if the device is found to be ineffective. Feel free to try several different collars to find the one that suits your pet perfectly.

Dogs are very intelligent creatures, each of which has its own character and behavior. I recommend using a comprehensive approach to training these pets. Never entirely rely on devices alone. Its effectiveness also depends on your participation in your dog behavior training. All these accessories should only serve as a convenient addition to your workouts.

Share your dog training experience with other readers and me. Have you managed to wean your pet from barking with collars? What other techniques have you used? What was most effective?

Matthew Farthing

Сontributing author at DoggoLab, Certified Dog Behavior Consultant.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      Doggolab